Cookies are one of the most popular treats around the world. We eat cookies in various parts of the day. You can consume this along with milk for breakfast or a snack in between meals. In other countries, cookies are stapled pairs for tea. When your sweet tooth strikes, you can even munch on cookies at the middle of the night! Cookies are also traditional pastries served during the holidays. Therefore, you can say that cookies are an inherent part of our daily and special menu.
Making your cookies is an even more delightful experience. The cookie press is an essential tool for making cookies that are all uniform in shape and size. Importantly, the cookie press makes the whole process easy because you only need to push through the shaft and a perfectly-shaped cookie comes out, ready for baking. Indeed, the best cookie press is perhaps an essential tool for home chefs who are crazy about making cookies.
How To Use A Cookie Press
Using the cookie press is very simple and straightforward. First, you roll the batter into a log at a size that fits the press’ shaft. Next, attach the desired disc into the other end of the shaft. Place the batter log into the shaft and secure. Hold the press vertically and press out the dough into a greased baking sheet. For electric-powered cookie presses, you only need to press a button, and the cookie comes out instantly. Repeat the process until you’ve expended all the dough and finally, bake the cookies.
If you’ve always made cookies by hand, you might begin to wonder how much time you would have saved and how beautiful your cookies would have been if you’ve used a cookie press all those times. Not to worry because there are several brands and models to choose from and most of them have cost-effective prices.
Comparison Table For The Best Cookie Press
Do you love to make cookies at home and wish become even better at it? A cookie press is an answer! Below is a comprehensive buying guide and review of the best five cookie presses, but you can always click on the product links above to read more reviews on Amazon.
Buying Guide For The Best Cookie Press
Are you fond of eating cookies as much as making them? It’s high time you invest in a cookie press. Not only will you be able to make cookies more efficiently, but these tools also allow you to make deviled eggs, frosting and biscuits. If you’re a chronic baker, a cookie press is something you’d love to have.
You’ll find cookie presses in various brands, make and model and shop for the first time; you could get overwhelmed with options. These tools perform the same job, but they can be so different in many ways. You need to find one that best meets your personal needs and preferences.
For you to make the most of your money and pick a cookie press that produces excellent, professional results here’s a set of criteria to consider.
Type (Manual Or Electric)
Cookie presses come in two types – electric or manual. Each has its own set of advantages and drawbacks. You want to consider how often you make cookies and how large a batch you make each time to decide which type between the two is most suitable for you.
An electric cookie press uses a power source to operate. That is ideal if you’re always making large batches of cookies or when you need to frost some cupcakes at a given time. It is more expensive than the manual type, but the added cost is an investment if you want to make cookies in a shorter span of time or if you’re running a cookie business.
On the other hand, the manual type is ideal if you’re making small to mid-sized batches of cookies. It is less costly and makes cookies at a slower pace compared to electric ones, but it is also more portable. You will be able to press out cookies even without being plugged into an electrical outlet.
Overall, when choosing between an electric or manual cookie press – economics, frequency, efficiency, and convenience are all important consideration.
Disc Attachments
Cookies are more pleasant to look at, and therefore more appealing to eat if you can make them into various shapes and sizes. A flat circular cookie is easy to make by hand, but it can be a struggle to make a star or tree-shaped cookies which are all look uniform without a cookie press. If you fancy making cookies in exciting shapes and forms, then you must consider the type and number of die-cast disc attachments that come with the product. You want to be able to make cookies in flower, sun, fleur, clover and a host of other beautiful shapes with just the switch of a disc.
Moreover, you want to look for rust-proof disc accessories which are easy to attach and detach. Also, opt for attachments that are BPA-free to ensure safety. Lastly, take a look at the design of the disc attachments to ensure these are shapes you’d love to make your cookies.
Material And Construction
It is also important to pay close attention to the structure of the cookie press. You want a cookie press that’s easy to handle and use, durable and pleasing to see.
Cookie presses come with various materials, but the most common are stainless steel and plastic. Stainless steel-made cookie presses are beautiful and durable, but they can also be more expensive. High-quality plastic cookie presses also do the job fairly well at a fraction of a price, but they’re not as durable as stainless steel ones. Whenever possible, pick a cookie press made with durable material and resistant to rust and corrosion.
Additionally, you want to make sure that the tool’s design and construction perfectly fit your needs. For instance, cookie presses with larger shafts allow you to make cookies without refilling frequently continuously, but larger shafts also require more pressure and effort to operate. However, if you’re buying the press mainly for children to use, smaller cookie presses are also ideal because they fit their hands and don’t require as much pressure to push the batter.
Ease Of Cleaning
Making and preparing cookies is in itself a messy process so opting for a cookie press that’s easy to clean and maintain. Opt for a cookie press that you can easily disassemble so that it’s easy to clean the nooks and crannies. It is also wise to pick a model with dishwasher-safe parts to even shorten the cleaning time.
The Best 5 Cookie Presses
1. Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press
The sleek and classic design of the Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press makes it quite an eye candy in any kitchen. The aluminium-clad body of the press doesn’t only make it aesthetically pleasing, but also lightweight and durable. It can stand the demands of cookie-making in large batches, without having to cut or roll dough.
The Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press also comes with 20 die-cut plates so you can choose from various shapes and patterns. Additionally, you can churn out cookies in large or small sizes just by replacing the disc. The very versatility of this cookie press gives you a lot of value for your money.
Additionally, this cookie press is an excellent choice for both baking newbies and connoisseurs. It comes with a detailed instruction and some free cookie/biscuit recipes to get you started. It’s also easy to handle and operate, so it takes the guesswork out of the picture. All in all, the Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press is looking like a great option when durability, longevity, aesthetics and efficiency are what you want.
PROS
- The material of the cookie press comes with durable stainless steel.
- Its classy, sleek and ergonomic design fit the look of any kitchen.
- 20 die-cast discs provide variety.
- It is a great press for making a large batch of cookies.
- It is easy to detach and clean.
CONS
- The case or shaft is not transparent so you wouldn’t know if you have any dough left without opening the cookie press.
- The shaft can get slippery and make plunging the dough out a bit of a struggle.
2. OXO Good Grips Cookie Press with Stainless Steel Disks and Storage Case
This cookie press is so simple and straightforward that it doesn’t even take any learning curve to master it. It is designed to expel out dough consistently and reliably, and the features all help for a fun and fast cookie-making session.
Perhaps the first thing that’s noticeable about the OXO cookie press is the fact that it has a clear, transparent shaft. That makes it easy to see how much dough you have left and whether it’s time for a refill. The barrel has a high-quality plastic, so it’s somewhat durable and easy to clean.
It also features a non-slip base that makes the press stable and secures around your grip as you expel one cookie after the next. That makes it comfortable to hold and use the press, even for kids and baking newbies.
Lastly, the product comes with 12 die-cut stainless steel discs in seasonal designs. If you’re looking to bake cookies in Christmas trees, snowflakes and wreathe for the holidays, this brand has it! And if you’d like to purchase additional discs that you can use year-round, OXO sells them at an extra cost.
Overall, this product is designed and configured for ease of use, comfortable grip and consistent results.
PROS
- The clear transparent barrel allows you to see how much dough you have in a snap.
- The non-slip base is perfect for stable and steady dispensing of cookies.
- It comes with 12 beautiful plates to choose.
- It is very user-friendly and perfect for kids and newbies learning to make and bake cookies for the first time.
CONS
- The plastic construction makes it less durable than stainless steel counterparts.
- The parts are not suitable for the dishwasher.
- The handle doesn’t feel as sturdy.
3. Norpro 3301 Cookie Press
The Norpro 3301 cookie press is the perfect choice when working with stiff dough. That is one of those cookie presses sold at the higher end of the price spectrum, but its features are suitable for its cost.
This cookie press is from Italy, and it’s the closest thing to make those delicious Italian cookies! It features a sturdy and durable metal construction, so it ensures the longevity of use. It comes with a wide opening, so it’s easy to put in the rolled cookie dough, plus its conveniently-sized handle allows for stable and consistent dispensing of cookies.
The Norpro 3301 cookie press produces professional looking cookies with utmost efficiency. It is easy to use. It is also easy to assemble and disassemble, making it convenient to use and clean. Additionally, it comes with 24 new die-cast designs so you can make cookies with greater versatility.
PROS
- This cookie press comes with a durable and rust-proof material.
- The product comes with 24 beautiful designs to create unique-looking cookies.
- It is easy to use and handle, as well as disassembles easily for cleaning.
CONS
- The parts are suitable for hand to wash only.
- Some users commented on the trigger or handle getting stuck.
4. Kuhn Rikon Clear Cookie Press with Decorating Tips and Storage Box
Designed and created by the popular brand, Kuhn Rikon, this cookie press is special in a lot of ways. In general, the design makes it easy to grip and handle even by kids attempting to make their first cookies, or by adults who want to make cookies on a whim. The shaft or container of the dough comes with high-quality transparent plastic which allows you to see the filling level instantly. Additionally, this durable plastic material won’t crack even under intense pressure, so it’s perfect for all types of bakers.
But kids will also love the variety of its 14 cookies discs in different shapes and designs. The can come up with nice-looking biscuits so quickly with little guidance.
It is also worth noting that the trigger or handle is detachable from the shaft and it’s easy to operate as a glue gun. You only need to exert the right amount of pressure and 30 or so cookies could come out with a single filling of the container. Additionally, since the whole device is so easy to operate, you can make cookies single-handedly without any struggle.
As for the ease of cleaning, this cookie press is easy to disassemble, and the parts are washable by hand or with the dishwasher. Once they are dry, you just need to store them in the storage container that comes with the product so that they’ll store neatly and won’t get lost in your drawers.
The Kuhn Rikon cookie press is certainly an excellent choice especially if you’re looking for one that does the job wonderfully at a reasonable price.
PROS
- The durable, transparent shaft allows you to see the amount of cookie dough you have left instantly.
- Operating by both kids and adults is easy.
- The shaft is removable from the trigger and allows for easy cleaning and re-filling.
- It comes with a storage box to keep discs and small parts in safely.
- It comes with 14 uniquely-designed discs to give cookies a more appealing appearance.
CONS
- It requires more pressure to expel out cookies than other models.
- Cookie dough continues to ooze even when you don’t press the trigger.
- Too thick of a batter could cause discs to pop out or forced out of the device.
5. DKST Kitchen Cookie Press
The DKST Kitchen Cookie Press allows you to create professional-looking cookies in minutes with its ergonomic design and intuitive operating mechanism.
This cookie press comes with a high-quality stainless steel, so it’s durable and rust-proof. It is for making cookies in various designs, as well as other treats like frosting over cakes and cupcakes, cheese straws and even churros.
Moreover, it claims to be bigger by 25% than similar models so it can accommodate more cookie dough, and ultimately, expel a larger number of cookies in one filling. It eliminates the need for the rolling pin and piping bag because the DKST Kitchen Cookie Press expels out one cookie after another in each press with consistent look, shape and form.
To further make things exciting, this product also comes with 25 different discs and eight decorative tips so you can make cookies, icing and biscuits with beautiful presentation. Plus, the designs are mostly seasonal, so you can be sure to have cookies aptly built for the main occasions of the year.
Lastly, keep the tool and all its accessories neatly inside the storage box that comes with the package.
PROS
- The cookie press was designed with a comfortable grip so your hands won’t have to exert as much pressure.
- It comes with 25 disc patterns and eight decorative tips for utmost versatility.
- It is made of durable and sturdy material so you can use the product for a longer period.
- The storage box makes it handy to keep the device and all accessories in one place.
CONS
- It requires more work to operate than other similar models.
- Also, it is not dishwasher-safe.
The Verdict
Cookies are traditional treats that won’t go anywhere shortly, so getting your very own cookie press is a great decision. And out of the five products presented in this list and considering every feature, the Marcato Atlas Deluxe Biscuit Maker Cookie Press stands out the most. It is ergonomic design; smooth operation and durable construction make it a worthy purchase. It is also reasonably-priced so making cookies quickly and conveniently with this product shouldn’t make a severe dent in your budget.
